Biden rule protecting privacy for abortions likely unlawful, judge rules

(Reuters) – A federal judge in Texas ruled that Democratic President Joe Biden’s administration likely exceeded its authority by issuing a rule strengthening privacy protections for women seeking abortions and for patients who receive gender transition treatments.

U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk in Amarillo on Sunday agreed to block the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services from enforcing the rule against a Texas doctor who through lawyers at a conservative Christian legal group challenged the regulation as unlawful.

The ruling by Kacsmaryk, who was appointed by Republican President-elect Donald Trump in his first term, issued the preliminary injunction a day before a Monday deadline for the doctor, Carmen Purl and her business to comply with the rule.

“Doctors and states should be able to protect patients from abuse,” said Julie Marie Blake of Alliance Defending Freedom, a lawyer for Purl. “The court rightly ruled that this unlawful rule change would have weaponized laws about privacy that have nothing to do with abortion or gender identity.”

HHS did not respond to a request for comment.

Kacsmaryk is best known for having in 2023 suspended the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s approval of the abortion drug mifepristone. The U.S. Supreme Court in June overturned an appeals court’s decision that had partially upheld Kacsmaryk’s ruling, preserving, for now, access to the medication.

The rule in Purl’s case was issued as part of the Biden administration’s pledge to take steps to support access to reproductive healthcare after the conservative-majority U.S. Supreme Court in 2022 overturned the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling that made access to abortion a constitutional right nationwide.

The HHS rule was issued in April and prohibits healthcare providers and insurers from giving information about a legal abortion to state law enforcement authorities who are seeking to punish someone in connection with that abortion.

It was issued under the authority to protect patient privacy given to HHS by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act in response to efforts by authorities in some Republican-led states that ban abortion, including Texas, to restrict out-of-state travel for abortion.

Purl, in a lawsuit filed in October, said the rule could prevent her from reporting abuse of a patient being pressured into getting an abortion or from reporting that a minor was scheduled for gender-affirming treatment in violation of state law.

© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: An unoccupied exam room at a Planned Parenthood center in White Plains, New York, U.S., April 3, 2020. Picture taken on April 3, 2020.  REUTERS/Liliana Engelbrecht/File Photo

HHS countered that the rule does not prevent reporting child abuse, since it only forbids disclosing an abortion to authorities who are seeking to impose punishment for it.

But Kacsmaryk said “even if a more nuanced reading of the 2024 Rule allowed child-abuse reporting to Texas (child protective services), a nonlawyer licensed physician is not equipped to navigate these intersecting legal labyrinths.”

Related Posts

Carbon Revolution Secures New $25 Million Financing Agreement with OIC and Existing Lenders

GEELONG, Australia, Dec. 23, 2024 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Carbon Revolution plc (Nasdaq: CREV) (the “Company”), a Tier 1 OEM supplier and the leading global manufacturer of lightweight advanced technology automotive…

Read more

Liquidity services director Edward Kolodzieski sells shares worth $877,340

Following these transactions, Kolodzieski now holds 17,229 shares of Liquidity Services’ common stock. The sales were conducted under a prearranged trading plan, as indicated in the filing. According to InvestingPro…

Read more

Carbon Streaming Announces Board and Management Changes

TORONTO, Dec. 23, 2024 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Carbon Streaming Corporation (Cboe CA: NETZ) (OTCQB: OFSTF) (FSE: M2Q) (Carbon Streaming or the Company) is pleased to announce the addition of Marin…

Read more

American strategic investment sees $14,447 in stock purchases

The purchases reflect continued interest and investment from the group, which holds significant ownership stakes in the company. Following these transactions, the group now owns a total of 918,368 shares…

Read more

Iberdrola acquires Avangrid shares for $2.55 billion

This acquisition is part of a merger agreement dated May 17, 2024, where Iberdrola’s wholly-owned subsidiary, Arizona Merger Sub, Inc., merged with Avangrid. As a result, Avangrid has become a…

Read more

France’s new premier selects Eric Lombard as finance minister

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter. France’s new prime minister François Bayrou has selected Eric Lombard,…

Read more

Leave a Reply