Chancellor forced to find more savings after watchdog doubts £5bn costing

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is facing a Labour backlash over welfare cuts, after she was forced to make last-minute savings to help balance the books in what is expected to be a grim Spring Statement on the economy on Wednesday.

Government officials said ministers had been forced to find £500mn of new cuts after a dispute with the Office for Budget Responsibility over how much welfare changes announced last week would save.

Labour MPs were already nervous about the welfare cuts — which work and pensions secretary Liz Kendall claimed would save £5bn a year — with public and private criticism of the plans mounting.

But the OBR then disputed the £5bn number and — even after the last-minute £500mn in additional cuts — has estimated that the savings will only save £3.4bn, according to people briefed on the forecasts. Reeves will therefore have to make cuts elsewhere.

“It all looks like a shambles,” said one person briefed on the preparations of the statement. “It has been pretty chaotic.”

Reeves will publish new OBR economic forecasts at about 12.30pm on Wednesday, which are expected to see the 2025 growth forecast halved from 2 per cent to about 1 per cent.

The chancellor has been left with a fiscal hole of about £15bn compared with her plans at her October Budget, which she will fill largely through cuts to public spending.

Reeves will publish alongside the OBR forecasts the government’s own impact assessment of welfare changes, which will spell out to Labour MPs the impact on some of the poorest in society.

Government officials said that universal credit incapacity benefits for new claimants will now be frozen until 2030 rather than increased in line with inflation, as part of the last-minute cuts.

The OBR’s refusal to “score” the £5bn of net welfare savings claimed by Kendall has created disarray just hours before the statement.

According to government insiders, Kendall came under pressure from 10 Downing Street and the Treasury to accelerate her announcement after details of her plan leaked to ITV News on March 8.

When Kendall gave her statement to MPs on March 18 — eight days before the Spring Statement — she admitted that the £5bn of net savings she hoped to achieve would have to be signed off by the OBR.

But according to government insiders, the fiscal forecaster reckoned only £2.9bn of net savings would materialise, leaving Kendall scrambling to find emergency additional cuts.

“The whole thing has been terribly handled,” said one person involved in finalising the Spring Statement. “A lot of Labour MPs will be pissed off about all of this — people feel a bit spooked by the whole thing.”

Ruth Curtice, head of the Resolution Foundation and former director of fiscal policy at the Treasury, said: “There is always back and forth on the costings, that is not unusual, and it is not extraordinary for those numbers to change reasonably late in the process.”

She added: “What is unique in this case is the government announced the changes in the House before knowing what the OBR thought they would be worth. That seems an odd way to make policy.”

Reeves, who will speak for about 25 minutes, will claim she has been forced to change economic tack because “the world is changing” — a reference to how Donald Trump has upended the global economic and security environment.

She will attempt to look on the bright side, pointing to efforts to secure an economic deal with the US in the coming days to avert punitive Trump tariffs. Reeves will also note efforts to secure closer trade ties with the EU.

The chancellor will also boost the UK’s defence spending by £2.2bn next year, arguing that the extra investment would help bolster British jobs and skills.

Reeves will insist on Wednesday she is providing “security” for the British people — both militarily and economically — but her speech to MPs will be dominated by dismal growth data, the yawning fiscal hole and an admission that things could get worse.

The extra military funding, which will come from new cuts to the overseas aid budget and the Treasury reserve, will take UK defence spending to 2.36 per cent of GDP in the 2025-26 financial year.

Reeves has already said military expenditure will hit 2.5 per cent in 2027 — an extra £6.4bn — funded by a raid on the foreign aid budget.

“As defence spending rises, I want the whole country to feel the benefits too,” she will say. John Healey, defence secretary, said the country faced “tough times”.

The chancellor’s address to MPs takes place in the shadow of Donald Trump, whose election as US president has forced Britain to increase defence spending.

Reeves has admitted that a Trumpian global trade war would create economic “headwinds” and further damp growth. Ministers deny Conservative claims that the chancellor is heralding a new era of “austerity”.

Darren Jones, chief secretary to the Treasury, on Tuesday briefed 75 ministers on the Spring Statement plan, which is expected to include a cut of at least £5bn a year from Whitehall spending totals later in the parliament. This will be on top of the welfare savings.

Jones insisted this was not “austerity”, pointing out that real spending on public services would rise every year in this parliament and was growing from a higher base, following Reeves’ big injection of cash into the NHS and other areas in her October Budget.

Paul Johnson, head of the Institute for Fiscal Studies think-tank, said talk of austerity “is way overblown in the context of what the government announced in October and by comparison with stated plans of the last government”.

However, if the economy continues to grow at a sluggish pace and a global trade war escalates, the chancellor could be forced to come back with more spending cuts — or tax rises — in her autumn Budget.

Reeves is battling negative sentiment over her handling of the economy. A YouGov survey found that only 16 per cent of voters thought the government was handling the economy well. Just 11 per cent hold a positive view of Reeves’ performance.

Related Posts

Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence group buys X for $45bn

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter. Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence group xAI has purchased social media…

Read more

CoreWeave chief Michael Intrator tests market faith in AI hype

CoreWeave chief executive Michael Intrator and executives at private equity giant Blackstone got together in the summer of 2023 in a WeWork in Brooklyn to hash out the terms of…

Read more

US tells French companies to comply with Trump’s anti-diversity order

Unlock the White House Watch newsletter for free Your guide to what the 2024 US election means for Washington and the world The Trump administration has sent a letter to…

Read more

US stocks tumble as deepening consumer gloom raises stagflation fears

Stay informed with free updates Simply sign up to the US inflation myFT Digest — delivered directly to your inbox. Wall Street stocks dropped on Friday as signs of strain…

Read more

Donald Trump says US must gain control of Greenland

Unlock the White House Watch newsletter for free Your guide to what the 2024 US election means for Washington and the world Donald Trump increased pressure on Denmark to cede…

Read more

Can Rachel Reeves start a retail investment revolution?

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter. This article is the latest part of the FT’s Financial…

Read more

Leave a Reply